Why hiring school buses for private use may soon prove costly
Hiring school buses for private business may soon prove to be a costly affair in case of road accidents.
In a precedent-setting decision, High Court judge Roselyn Aburili says it would be wrong to compel an insurance company to settle claims that arise from liability not contemplated by the legislature and even then, which is not the subject of an insurance policy between the parties involved.
The judge said should the insurer be forced to settle such claims, it would not only have the effect of assigning on parties that which they did not contract, but also against the provisions of the law.
“The end result would be to confer an unnecessary benefit on an undeserving party while punishing the insurer for that which it did not contract and/or acquiesce to,” said the judge in a decision delivered in Kisumu on August 8, 2024.
The judge said boards of management of schools should beware, and called on those who hire school buses to read the insurance policy in respect of the usage of those buses before they part with any money and risk the lives and limb of the innocent ‘unauthorised passengers’.
“I do trust and hope that this brief judgment will be circulated to all schools in the country through the county directors of education to alert school management boards, of the dangers associated with the practice, which danger only comes to the fore when there is an accident upon suits being filed by those affected,” said the judge.
Justice Aburili made the decision in a case filed by Old Mutual General Insurance Kenya Limited against the board of directors of Oder Boys Boarding Special School in Kisumu.
In the case, members of the Seventh Day Adventist, who happen to be the sponsors of the school, hired the school bus on April 23, 2023, to ferry them to a church function in Kakamega County.
The bus was involved in an accident along the Kisumu-Kakamega Road and several passengers were injured.
The injured passengers later filed cases before the Small Claims Court seeking compensation but the insurer opposed the cases, arguing that it was not liable since the bus was not being for the purpose it was insured against, at the time of the accident.
The insurance firm stated that it was in express terms of the insurance policy under the general exceptions that the company would not be liable in respect of any accident, loss, damage or liability caused, sustained or incurred while the motor vehicle was being used for purpose it was insured for.
The school defended the claims, stating that the bus was registered in the name of the school and as the SDA was the sponsor of the school, it was authorised to use the bus when the need arose, which the Church did on the material date, ferrying church members to Kakamega having fueled the bus and paid the driver the daily stipend.
Although the claims were later withdrawn, Justice Aburili said it is common, especially during crusades and other religious gatherings in the country’s major cities, to see all school vehicles “lined up from all parts of the nation in their beautiful yellow colours, scaling heights and going down the valleys, leading to those crusades, carrying believers or worshippers”.
However, the judge said, the insurance policy that they take out happens to exclude those kinds of passengers otherwise known as unauthorised passengers.
“When accidents occur, the policy is avoided or voided and the injured passengers or dead passengers’ loved ones end up being mere pious explorers in the pursuit of justice and bearing barren decrees as the schools can barely bear the burden of settling such claims which are left to them,” the judge pointed out.
Justice Aburili said it was clear that schools do not read and adhere to the terms of the binding insurance contracts.
“Those contracts are written in very small prints to discourage readership. The insured often assume the risks and mostly, is out of ignorance. The unauthorised passengers, on the other hand, are oblivious of the risks. The insurance companies assume no risk and rightly, legally, which risks are not covered by the contract of insurance,” added the court.
The court said the liability had been expressly excluded when the bus was not being used for the purposes for which it had been insured.
skiplagat@ke.nationmedia.com
Shows
See AllAM Live
AM Live is NTV's morning current affairs show that sets the agenda for the day with insightful panels every weekday.
Business Redefined
Business Redefined is Kenya’s premier thought leadership platform for unpacking matters regarding economic and finance policy as well demystifying complex developments in the region’s capital markets.
Comedies
A collection of our premium content. Diam curabitur vehicula A collection of our premium content. Diam curabitur vehicula
Entertainment
A collection of our premium content. Diam curabitur vehicula A collection of our premium content. Diam curabitur vehicula
Full Episodes
A collection of our premium content. Diam curabitur vehicula A collection of our premium content. Diam curabitur vehicula
Gumzo La Sato
Gumzo La Sato is a live social issues show that aims to create awareness about issues affecting the larger society. The discussions range from Parenting, Marital bliss and struggles, Oppression, violence, and all matters of the Heart.
Health Diary
Health Diary is a weekly show that highlights different types of diseases/conditions and seeks ways to prevent, treat/manage them. The show debunks this through real life stories and also feature specialists in different fields, to offer medical advice on the same.
Letter To My Younger Self
Letter To My Younger Self is a podcast where guests get to write a letter to their younger self, from which Maxine formulates questions to ask them during the hour-long show.
Nation Reports
Nation Reports is a weekly podcast offers an opportunity for listeners to interact with various reporters and journey with them as they unravel the biggest most emotive stories.
One Health Lens Podcast
Discussing health matters and human stories from Kenya and across Africa. We talk big picture from people to policy, ecosystems, and everything in between. Follow us on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/onehealthlens
Paradise Lost
Paradise Lost peeks through the story of Louis Otieno, the times, and everything in between.
Speaking of GEN Z
Speaking of Gen Z brings you entertaining but meaningful conversations about a generation that is trying to navigate through adulthood. Join hosts Michelle, Jackie and Esther as they unravel all things Gen Z.
Sport On
Sport-On is a 30-minute sports magazine show on NTV and 3 hours on NATION FM. The show seeks to give the sports “fanatics” and “funatics” comprehensive and in-depth coverage of sports both locally and internationally.
Tech-over
The extent of technological growth is beyond mere acknowledgment; it has seamlessly integrated into our daily existence. A few years ago, the notion of paying electricity bills through mobile money or recharging with 'tokens' in Kenya seemed inconceivable. Online product sales were considered distant, and artificial intelligence is rapidly reshaping various facets of our lives. Amidst these technological leaps, those with a solid understanding of tech can navigate challenges, seize opportunities, and build a sustainable livelihood. Tech over Show aims to be the platform facilitating discussions among thought leaders, innovators, tech companies, and the government, addressing challenges and opportunities in Kenya's thriving tech industry.
Thamani
Thamani is a business show which is dedicated to emerging issues regarding micro, small and medium size businesses.
The Politalk podcast
This is The Politalk podcast. Here we look into the ins and outs of everything Kenyan politics. We pull no punches and have no reason to sugarcoat anything that matters to Kenyans.
The Trend
A two-hour-long live show that airs on Fridays. The show focuses on what is current in the entertainment industry, controversial and popular across all media platforms targeting those aged between 25 and 35 years.
The trend podcast
The trend podcast highlights and captures the best of banter from #TTTT segment that airs every Friday on NTV. It's the TTTT EXTRA
The Wicked Edition
The Wicked Edition with Dr. King’ori seeks to address serious issues through humour and relatable wit. It is a two-part half hour show filmed in front of a live audience
Trending
A collection of our premium content. Diam curabitur vehicula A collection of our premium content. Diam curabitur vehicula
Twende
Twende is a travel show that highlights beautiful, unique, diverse locations, people, and cultures. The show offers fresh perspectives on familiar locations and memorable experiences in new ones.
Unscripted
This Saturday evening lifestyle show lets viewers share their stories and life experiences as openly & honestly for the purpose of shifting the culture of silence.
VIP Access
VIP ACCESS is Anyiko Owoko’s YouTube and podcast show on Music and Culture dedicated to promoting Africa’s most promising talent and creatives. This podcast grants you VIP access into timeless interviews while providing a platform for rising as well as established artists across the continent. Since launching in 2018, Anyiko has interviewed over 70 African music stars.
WADR
This weekly news show aims to have all sides of debate but not be constrained by it, listen to main voices in the contest but not allow them to hold the viewers hostage, entertain debate but allow push back with all due respect.
When death do us part
In this podcast, three widowers openly speak about the process of grief, how they found themselves exposed to the emotional turmoil of losing their wives, and how society still does not know how to deal with them.
Your World
Your World is a health, wellness and variety show. It provides a platform for audiences and experts to share their experiences on how to improve or manage health issues, across Kenya and the Africa region.